BMW F 900 XR 2020 vs. BMW S 1000 R 2017

The BMW F 900 XR 2020 and the BMW S 1000 R 2017 are both sporty touring motorcycles with inline engines and chain transmissions. However, there are several differences between the two models.

In terms of power, the BMW S 1000 R 2017 has a more powerful engine with 165 HP compared to the BMW F 900 XR 2020's 105 HP. The S 1000 R also has a higher torque of 114 Nm compared to the F 900 XR's 92 Nm. This difference in power and torque makes the S 1000 R more suitable for high-performance riding and track use, while the F 900 XR is better suited for touring and everyday riding.

Both motorcycles have liquid-cooled engines and four-stroke cycles, but the F 900 XR has a smaller displacement of 895cc compared to the S 1000 R's 999cc. This means that the S 1000 R has a larger engine and potentially better overall performance.

In terms of suspension, both motorcycles have telescopic front forks and swingarm rear suspension with monoshock absorbers. However, the S 1000 R has the advantage of dynamic suspension, which adjusts automatically to different riding conditions. This can provide a more comfortable and controlled ride compared to the F 900 XR's standard suspension.

BMW F 900 XR 2020

The chassis of the F 900 XR is made of steel, while the S 1000 R has an aluminum frame. This could result in a slight difference in weight and handling characteristics, with the aluminum frame potentially offering better agility and maneuverability.

Both motorcycles have dual-disc front brakes with four-piston calipers and radial technology, providing excellent stopping power. However, the S 1000 R's brakes are described as very powerful, which could give it an advantage in terms of braking performance.

In terms of dimensions, both motorcycles have a 17-inch front tire diameter and a 17-inch rear tire diameter. The F 900 XR has a narrower front tire width of 120mm compared to the S 1000 R's 190mm. This could result in slightly different handling characteristics, with the narrower tire providing better agility and the wider tire offering better stability.

The F 900 XR has a longer wheelbase of 1518mm compared to the S 1000 R's 1439mm. This could affect the stability and maneuverability of the motorcycles, with the longer wheelbase potentially providing better stability at high speeds.

In terms of weight, the F 900 XR weighs 211kg with ABS, while the S 1000 R weighs 205kg with ABS. The difference in weight is minimal and is unlikely to have a significant impact on the overall performance of the motorcycles.

BMW S 1000 R 2017

Both motorcycles have a fuel capacity of over 15 liters, with the S 1000 R having a slightly larger capacity of 17.5 liters. This could result in a slightly longer range for the S 1000 R compared to the F 900 XR.

In terms of strengths, the F 900 XR has a powerful and durable engine, variable ergonomics, sufficient wind protection, excellent Brembo brakes, an elegant appearance, and a wide range of accessories. On the other hand, the S 1000 R is praised for its fantastic sound, powerful engine, excellent maneuverability, wide range of equipment options and accessories, and powerful brakes. The S 1000 R also has the advantage of semi-active suspension, which eliminates the need for manual adjustment.

As for weaknesses, the F 900 XR is criticized for its behavioral sound, while the S 1000 R's weaknesses include the use of lower-quality stock tires and an inactive riding position on the track.

In conclusion, the BMW F 900 XR 2020 and the BMW S 1000 R 2017 are both impressive motorcycles with their own strengths and weaknesses. The F 900 XR is more suitable for touring and everyday riding, while the S 1000 R is better suited for high-performance riding and track use. Ultimately, the choice between the two models depends on the rider's preferences and intended use.