BMW R 1200 GS 2017 vs. Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 Special 2021

The BMW R 1200 GS 2017 and the Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 Special 2021 are both popular models in the adventure motorcycle segment. While they have some similarities, there are also notable differences between the two.

In terms of the engine and drivetrain, the BMW R 1200 GS 2017 features a Boxer type engine with a displacement of 1170cc. It produces a power output of 125 HP and a torque of 125 Nm. The transmission is a shaft drive, and it has 2 cylinders. On the other hand, the Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 Special 2021 has a V-type engine with a displacement of 1252cc. It generates a higher power output of 150 HP and a torque of 127 Nm. The transmission is a chain drive, and it also has 2 cylinders. Overall, the Pan America offers a more powerful and sporty engine compared to the R 1200 GS.

In terms of suspension, the R 1200 GS 2017 has a front suspension with support and preload adjustment, while the rear suspension is a single swinging arm with preload adjustment. The Pan America 1250 Special 2021, on the other hand, features a front suspension with upside-down telescopic forks and adjustable compression, preload, and rebound settings. The rear suspension is a swinging arm with adjustable compression, preload, and rebound settings. The Pan America offers more advanced suspension with a wider range of adjustment options, making it more suitable for off-road riding.

BMW R 1200 GS 2017

In terms of the chassis, the R 1200 GS 2017 has a steel frame with a double tube design that supports the engine. The Pan America 1250 Special 2021, on the other hand, features an aluminum frame with a double cradle design. The aluminum frame provides better rigidity and lighter weight, contributing to improved handling and maneuverability.

Both motorcycles feature dual-disc front brakes for effective stopping power. The tire sizes are also the same, with a 19-inch front tire and a 17-inch rear tire. The seat height is also identical at 850mm. However, the Pan America has a slightly longer wheelbase of 1585mm compared to the R 1200 GS's 1507mm. This may result in better stability and straight-line performance for the Pan America.

In terms of weight, the R 1200 GS 2017 weighs 238 kg (with ABS), while the Pan America 1250 Special 2021 is slightly heavier at 258 kg (with ABS). The Pan America's larger engine and additional features contribute to its higher weight.

In terms of fuel capacity, the R 1200 GS 2017 has a 20-liter fuel tank, while the Pan America 1250 Special 2021 has a slightly larger 21.2-liter fuel tank. This gives the Pan America a slight advantage in terms of fuel range.

Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 Special 2021

In terms of strengths, the R 1200 GS 2017 is known for its mature concept, strong engine, easy handling, powerful brakes, adjustable modes and traction control, wide range of equipment options, good image, and high resale value. On the other hand, the Pan America 1250 Special 2021 is praised for its sporty engine, comfortable seating position, passenger-friendly design, extensive electronics, original HD saddlebag system, wind protection, cornering ABS, cornering traction control, optional seat lowering when stopped, and good off-road capabilities.

However, both motorcycles have their weaknesses. The R 1200 GS 2017 has many additional features that come at an extra cost, and its exposed boxer engine may be vulnerable in very difficult terrain. The Pan America 1250 Special 2021, on the other hand, may experience engine heating in urban riding conditions, and it does not have a gear lever available, which may be a drawback for some riders.

In conclusion, the BMW R 1200 GS 2017 and the Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 Special 2021 are both capable adventure motorcycles with their own strengths and weaknesses. The R 1200 GS offers a mature and versatile package, while the Pan America provides a more sporty and off-road focused experience. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on the rider's preferences and intended usage.