Honda X-ADV 2017 vs. Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020
Honda X-ADV 2017
Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020
Vue d’ensemble - Honda X-ADV 2017 vs Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020
The Honda X-ADV 2017 and the Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020 are both impressive models from Honda, but they have some key differences.
In terms of engine specifications, the Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020 has a more powerful engine with 102 HP and 105 Nm of torque compared to the Honda X-ADV 2017's 55 HP and 68 Nm of torque. The Africa Twin also has a larger displacement of 1084cc compared to the X-ADV's 745cc. This difference in power and displacement makes the Africa Twin more suitable for off-road adventures and long-distance riding.
Both models have a liquid-cooled engine and use fuel injection for efficient performance. They also have electric starters and multiplate clutches in an oil bath. However, the X-ADV 2017 has a dual-clutch transmission, which provides smooth and seamless gear shifts, while the Africa Twin 2020 has a traditional gearshift transmission. The X-ADV's dual-clutch transmission is a standout feature that sets it apart from other scooters.
In terms of suspension, both models have upside-down telescopic forks at the front and monoshock absorbers at the rear. However, the Africa Twin 2020 has a longer travel distance for both the front and rear suspension, with 230mm and 220mm respectively. This makes the Africa Twin better equipped for off-road riding and handling rough terrains compared to the X-ADV's 154mm and 150mm of travel.
Honda X-ADV 2017
Both models have steel frames, but the X-ADV 2017 has a twin-tube, tubular frame design, while the Africa Twin 2020 has a double cradle frame design. The choice of frame design impacts the overall rigidity and handling characteristics of the motorcycles.
In terms of braking, both models have double disc brakes at the front and a single disc brake at the rear. They also both feature ABS as an advanced rider assistance system, ensuring safe and controlled braking in various conditions.
The X-ADV 2017 has a smaller fuel tank capacity of 13 liters compared to the Africa Twin 2020's 18.8 liters. This gives the Africa Twin a longer range, making it more suitable for long-distance rides.
In terms of dimensions and weights, the X-ADV 2017 has a slightly longer wheelbase of 1588mm compared to the Africa Twin 2020's 1575mm. The seat height of the Africa Twin is also slightly higher at 850mm compared to the X-ADV's 820mm. The Africa Twin 2020 is slightly lighter with a kerb weight of 226kg compared to the X-ADV's 239kg.
Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020
Both models come equipped with LED headlights, which provide excellent visibility and energy efficiency.
In terms of strengths, the X-ADV 2017 has a perfectly functioning dual-clutch transmission, high-quality chassis components for road and off-road, a functional and easy-to-read display, and an eye-catching look that stands out. On the other hand, the Africa Twin 2020 has a high-torque engine, sophisticated electronic driving aids, a wonderfully functioning dual-clutch transmission (optional), a touch-screen color display, good ergonomics, and long-distance capability. The Africa Twin also has a windshield that is perfect for off-roading.
In terms of weaknesses, the X-ADV 2017 has limited storage space under the seat compared to other scooters, a very wide handlebar that can be distracting in city traffic, a wide footwell, and a chain drive that requires more maintenance compared to belt drives. The Africa Twin 2020 has a flood of buttons on the left handlebar that may not be very clear, handguards that are not very robust for off-road use, and a windshield that offers manageable protection.
Overall, the Honda X-ADV 2017 is a unique scooter with off-road capabilities, while the Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020 is a versatile and powerful adventure motorcycle. The choice between the two ultimately depends on the rider's preferences and intended use.
Caractéristiques techniques Honda X-ADV 2017 par rapport à Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020
Avantages et inconvénients en comparaison
Avantages et inconvénients en comparaison
Honda X-ADV 2017
Avec le X-ADV, Honda a fait preuve d'une grande audace et s'est lancé dans le grand bain. L'idée d'un scooter tout-terrain est complètement nouvelle, mais elle a porté ses fruits. L'allure du X-ADV est puissante et donne l'impression qu'il peut aller n'importe où. La propulsion est également bonne. La boîte de vitesses DCT fonctionne parfaitement avec le bicylindre et fait du Honda X-ADV un excellent scooter polyvalent.
Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020
L'Africa Twin est pour moi une moto d'aventure comme une moto d'aventure doit l'être. C'était déjà le cas pour le modèle précédent et cela n'a pas changé avec l'augmentation de la cylindrée et de la puissance. D'une part, parce que la puissance de 102 ch est restée raisonnable et que Honda a même réussi à perdre quelques kilos par rapport à la CRF1000L. Il lui restait donc la polyvalence, elle fonctionne aussi bien sur l'autoroute qu'en off-road. Le châssis absorbe presque toutes les irrégularités, le moteur reste souverain dans toutes les situations, l'ergonomie et le confort d'assise sont exemplaires. Une moto pour tous les jours, mais aussi pour les grands voyages - quelle que soit la destination.
Comparaison des prix Prix moyen du marché Honda X-ADV vs Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin
There are a few key differences between a Honda X-ADV 2017 and a Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020. In terms of price, the actual average price of a Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020 is about 48% higher. A Honda X-ADV 2017 experiences a loss of 100 USD in one year of ownership. This is offset by a loss of 640 USD for a Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020. Compared to Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin 2020 there are more Honda X-ADV 2017 bikes available on the 1000PS.de Marketplace, specifically 9 compared to 7. It takes less time to sell a Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin with 106 days compared to 111 days for the Honda X-ADV. Since model year 2017 1000PS.de editors have written 22 reviews for the Honda X-ADV and 28 reviews for the Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin since model year 2020. The first review for the Honda X-ADV was published on 9/15/2016 and now has more than 31,500 views. This compares to more than 109,400 views for the first review on Honda CRF1100L Africa Twin published on 9/23/2019.
