BMW R12 vs. Royal Enfield Shotgun 650

BMW R12 vs. Royal Enfield Shotgun 650

2 price classes, yet still a few things in common

Two worlds collide: the BMW R12, a luxurious power cruiser from Bavaria, meets the Royal Enfield Shotgun 650, the charismatic underdog from India. What happens when David takes on Goliath? We put it to the test and were surprised to find the two bikes actually have a few things in common!

nastynils

nastynils

published on 11/24/2024

22,758 Views

Hard to believe! Both bikes can be ridden in the EU with 48 hp, meaning you can pilot them on an A2 licence. Even the big 1200cc BMW can be ordered with 48 hp instead of 95 hp. Astonishing!

On one side stands the brand-new BMW R12, a statement on two wheels representing everything the Bavarian Motor Works has perfected in recent years. On the other side stands the Royal Enfield Shotgun 650, a likeable challenger from India rolling onto the market with an unbeatable price-performance ratio. The question that arises: can the budget-friendly challenger hold its own against the luxury cruiser from Munich? We rode both bikes extremely intensively during the Balkan Rally. Both bikes had to cover a distance of 2,500 km. Both bikes were ridden by 8 test riders. There was plenty of swapping back and forth, followed by animated discussion about the bikes. Which bike appeals to which rider?

What is the Balkan Rally?

The Balkan Rally is no ordinary motorcycle tour, but a mix of adventure, retro charm and exclusive indulgence. Originally conceived for classic cars, over the years the event has also opened up to classic and retro bikes. The starting gun traditionally goes off in Budapest, from where participants ride scenic routes through the Balkans to the coast in the Kotor region. The organisers place great emphasis on comfort - the stages always end at select, luxurious hotels. Accompanied by an espresso mobile and evening champagne and wine tastings, the rally offers a stylish supporting programme that encourages exchange with car and motorcycle enthusiasts. But that's not all: during the daily stages, participants have to work out their arrival time by solving riddles and mastering photo challenges. Riding too fast or too slow earns penalty points - so it's all about finding the perfect balance. Despite the rally's car-focused orientation, motorcyclists feel welcome in the group, because the relaxed atmosphere and varied tasks make the rally a unique experience that goes far beyond an ordinary tour. In 2025 the Balkan Rally will once again offer new routes and challenges - an event that should be on every retro and motorcycle lover's bucket list.

More information about the rally here.

The 1000PS crew's gear for the 2024 Balkan Rally

The entire crew relied on cool retro-style gear from Held for the trip. Particularly worth mentioning is the Sirmione Gore-Tex sneaker as well as the great Jester leather jacket.

We used the same luggage solution for all bikes: the Legend Gear tail bag from SW-Motech. It offers versatile mounting options and is very affordable and compact. The bag had to endure almost 3,000 km on 8 different bikes in adverse weather conditions!

Before the rally we thoroughly waterproofed our gear with PROTEX spray from MOTOREX. During the rally we used the small, refillable mini chain spray cans from MOTOREX.

Communication worked really well this time. The entire team was connected via Cardo Packtalk devices. The batteries lasted all day and the devices were 100% waterproof. Sound quality was great, and combining "navigation prompts" + "music" + "communication" worked flawlessly. Even the occasional phone call couldn't overload the system. Highly recommended for big group adventures!

For helmets, the whole team went with the HJC V10. The helmet offers a wide range of design options and matched our beautiful bikes wonderfully. On the long tour we enjoyed the high level of wearing comfort.

For navigation we had roadbooks from race control available. However, we tried to trace the route as accurately as possible using Calimoto. For the journey to Budapest, and especially on the way back from Kotor, we opted for the "fastest" motorway option due to weather conditions. Anyone wanting to ride the tour in good weather should set the Calimoto sliders to "twisty" for those sections. Here is the link to the rough route.

The 1000PS crew at the 2024 Balkan Rally

1000PS at the 2024 Balkan Rally

1000PS at the 2024 Balkan Rally

Looks and first impressions: Class meets charm

The moment the Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 stands in front of me, it's clear: this isn't about technology showdowns or horsepower madness. The Enfield radiates pure retro charm without ever feeling contrived. Its classic design harks back to a bygone era of motorcycling, when speed wasn't everything and you could still feel the wind through your fingers. The slim, elegant tank, the round headlight and the harmoniously curved lines make it a real eye-catcher.

The BMW R12, on the other hand, struts in like a rock star who is fully aware of himself. Everything about this bike screams "Boxer BMW!": the magnificent, transverse boxer engine juts imposingly into the airflow, the teardrop-shaped tank flows seamlessly into the massive front end. It's a bike that radiates "I can do it all" and draws every glance - even standing still. While the Royal Enfield takes us on a journey into the past, the BMW brings modern motorcycling pleasure with a pinch of nostalgia.

Engine character: Slowing down versus sheer power

Hidden beneath the Royal Enfield's slim tank is a 648cc parallel-twin engine producing 47 hp. This machine invites you to cruise. The power isn't designed to break records - but that's not the point here either. It's more about relaxed riding, the feeling of becoming one with the road. The engine feels as if it was beamed straight from the 60s into the present, and that's exactly its appeal. Simple, honest and unfussed - a bike that slows you down and makes you forget everyday life.

The BMW R12 is the complete opposite. Here, a 1170cc boxer engine provides propulsion. With 95 hp on the spec sheet, the BMW shows that it's not just relaxed but can also be quick. The boxer is a powerhouse that nevertheless behaves smoothly and in a refined manner. It has that typical boxer balance, allowing for gentle cruising just as much as dynamic rides on twisty roads. The power is available at all times, the thrust comes evenly, without haste but with the necessary punch. The sound of the boxer? Pure symphony! Compared to the modern 1250cc or 1300cc BMW boxer engines, it also brings plenty of raw character. It shakes a little. The engine braking effect isn't as smoothed-over as on the modern engines, and you get the feeling of piloting a huge machine.

Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 at the 2024 Balkan Rally comparison

Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 at the 2024 Balkan Rally comparison

The big BMW is lighter than the small Royal Enfield

How much does a BMW R 12 cost?
Here you will find an overview of the price level of new and used motorbikes!

The BMW tips the scales at 229 kg, while the Royal Enfield weighs 233 kg. Nevertheless, the Royal Enfield is overall the somewhat more accessible bike. The engine is simply tamer, the bike demands less attention and concentration. That said, the R12 can also be piloted precisely and effortlessly. During our rally, our new colleague Amelie completed a completely rain-soaked day's stage. She'd only had her full motorcycle licence for a few months, and the tour through the Balkans was her first big trip on a large bike. She got on wonderfully with the 1200cc BMW and always felt comfortable and safe on the supposedly heavy bike. On the other hand, the Shotgun 650 also captured the hearts of the experienced riders. In the saddle, things never got boring - riding it was pure fun. On the long stages, however, the BMW was rated more highly. Its advantages were of a pragmatic nature though: heated grips, cruise control and greater range!

For anyone who loves comfort and technology, the BMW R12 leaves almost nothing to be desired. Heated grips, cornering ABS, traction control, riding modes - it simply has everything. Riding comfort is excellent, the seat still feels comfortable even after several hours. Anyone planning long tours is extremely well catered for with the R12.

The Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 offers less bells and whistles, but instead a return to the essentials. The seat is comfortable, but simply properly soft. Traction control? Not to be found. Here it's all about pure riding, without distraction from assistance systems or riding modes. For some this may be a drawback, for others it's exactly what motorcycling is all about. The Enfield focuses on the essentials - and it does that damn well.

The chassis of the two bikes couldn't be more different. The BMW feels really at home on good asphalt. The chassis feels surprisingly sporty and the bike tracks precisely and stably. The Royal Enfield, in contrast, feels a bit more relaxed and softer. The BMW's short suspension travel and firm setup aren't a problem over most of the tour. But on harder hits, you get them passed straight through mercilessly. The BMW's 90mm of suspension travel simply offers too little reserve on bad asphalt. The Royal Enfield is softer and feels less composed over bumps. Unevenness in the asphalt causes less pain here, but you have to close the throttle. Overall, the Royal Enfield is more relaxed, more laid-back and softer. The BMW is sportier, sharper, but also more merciless than the Royal Enfield on bad asphalt.

BMW R12 at the 2024 Balkan Rally comparison

BMW R12 at the 2024 Balkan Rally comparison

Long stages - more power please!

The Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 isn't a mile-muncher. It cuts a good figure on long stretches, but at motorway speeds things get a bit uncomfortable. When overtaking you have to push the bike a bit and it just doesn't feel as harmonious. The Royal Enfield also covered 2,900 km during the rally. Riders always dismounted with a grin. But on the motorway stages, the Enfield simply wasn't the most popular bike.

The BMW R12, on the other hand, is what you'd call a genuine long-distance king. Here, the journey has only just begun once you have to stop for the first time after 200-300 km. It practically soaks up the road, the kilometres just fly by. Seat comfort and engine performance are tailor-made for the long tour - whether across Germany or along the Adriatic coast. Anyone serious about travelling on two wheels won't get past the BMW.

Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 at the 2024 Balkan Rally comparison

Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 at the 2024 Balkan Rally comparison

Both bikes surprised us

The R12 pleasantly surprised us during the test. We expected a budget version of the big R18. But we got a machine that hit the mark spot on. It's simply great fun to go touring on this machine. On top of that it looks fantastic and offers a unique boxer bike feeling. This bike is great. Why haven't I bought one already? Right after the first day's stage I fired up the configurator on the BMW Motorrad website. In my desired configuration, the good piece costs over 20,000 euros. Cheaper than an R18 or a Harley, but a bit too expensive as a third bike in the garage. But anyone looking for a charming cruiser they'll actually want to ride a lot will be very happy with the R12. A cruiser for real riders.

The situation is different for Royal Enfield. You look at a bike that gamely goes along with everything and also has a cool image. Then you take a look at the price list and are pleasantly surprised. It's astonishing how much bike you get for this money. Depending on country/taxes, the bike costs around 8,000 euros. The machine shone in the paddock among Ferraris and Porsches and put on a confident showing. It's a bike you'd happily add to the garage as an extra. A bike for special occasions that turns heads and is ready for a variety of rides without fuss. In any case, the cruiser segment was enriched by two great bikes in 2024.

Technical data compared

-BMW R 12Royal Enfield Shotgun 650
Engine type2-cylinder boxer engineParallel-twin
Displacement1170cc648cc
Power95 hp / 6500 rpm47 hp / 7250 rpm
Torque110 Nm / 6000 rpm52.3 Nm / 5650 rpm
Transmission6-speed6-speed
Front suspension45mm USD fork / 90mm travelUSD fork / 120mm travel
Rear suspensionMonoshock / 90mm travelTwin shocks / 90mm travel
Front brakeDual disc brakeDisc brake
Rear brakeSingle disc brakeDisc brake
ABSCornering ABSStandard ABS
Traction controlLean-angle sensitiveNo
Seat height754mm795mm
Weight (wet weight)229 kg233.5 kg
Tank volume18 l13.5 l
Consumption (estimated)5.0 l/100km4.5 l/100km
Range (approx.)360 km300 km
Price (approx.)€17,000€8,000
Special featuresHeated grips, riding modes, TFT displayClassic design, lower price

2024 retro bike comparison

Balkan Rally

BMW R12 at the 2024 Balkan Rally comparison

BMW R12 at the 2024 Balkan Rally comparison

How much does a Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 cost?
Here you will find an overview of the price level of new and used motorbikes!
nastynils

BMW R 12 2024 - Experiences and Expert Review

nastynils

4.0 / 51000PS Test Verdict based on 3 articles, 2024

The BMW R12 is more than just a stylish cruiser. It offers comfort, performance and surprising agility - a bike you can love equally for long trips and short outings.


Boxer engine that feels powerful

Lots of charisma yet still smooth throttle response

Comfortable but low seating position

Agile handling despite cruiser design

Excellent brakes

Good lean-angle sensitive traction control

High-quality cornering ABS

Comfortable riding on long stretches

Great equipment options available

Classic design with a modern touch

Stable road holding

Good feedback even on slippery roads

Uncomfortable chassis on bad roads

Pegs scrape the ground quickly with a sporty riding style

Relatively high effort required at the clutch

Limited suspension travel restricts the bike's all-round character somewhat

nastynils

Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 2024 - Experiences and Expert Review

nastynils

3.0 / 51000PS Test Verdict based on 4 articles, 2024

Slowing down on two wheels with heart and character. It's a bike for anyone who wants to feel the wind, enjoy the scenery and let their soul dangle. With its relaxed power delivery, classic cruiser looks and solid build quality, it wins over the hearts of purists in search of the original.


Relaxed riding comfort

Classic cruiser design

Solid build quality

Characterful riding experience

Affordable price

Modern features (USB, LED lights)

Easy handling

Pleasant seating position for long rides

Above-average consumption

Limited luggage options

Weak front brake

Uncomfortable knee angle on long stages

Heavy weight when manoeuvring

Underdamped chassis on bad asphalt

More from 1000PS Magazine

BMW R12 vs. Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 Images

Source: 1000PS

BMW R 12 2024 - Image 1
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 2
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 3
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 4
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 5
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 6
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 7
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 8
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 9
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 10
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 11
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 12
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 13
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 14
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 15
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 16
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 17
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 18
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 19
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 20
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 21
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 22
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 23
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 24
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 25
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 26
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 27
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 28
BMW R 12 2024 - Image 29
Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 2024 - Image 30
Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 2024 - Image 31
Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 2024 - Image 32
Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 2024 - Image 33
Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 2024 - Image 34
Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 2024 - Image 35
Royal Enfield Shotgun 650 2024 - Image 36