BMW S 1000 R 2021 vs. Yamaha MT-09 2021

BMW S 1000 R 2021

BMW S 1000 R 2021

Yamaha MT-09 2021

Yamaha MT-09 2021

Loading...

Overview - BMW S 1000 R 2021 vs Yamaha MT-09 2021

The BMW S 1000 R 2021 and the Yamaha MT-09 2021 are both naked bikes with similar technical specifications. However, there are some key differences between the two models.

In terms of engine power, the BMW S 1000 R has a significant advantage with 165 HP compared to the Yamaha MT-09's 119 HP. This makes the BMW more powerful and capable of delivering a thrilling riding experience. The BMW also has a higher torque of 114 Nm compared to the Yamaha's 93 Nm, providing better acceleration and responsiveness.

Both bikes have in-line engines with fuel injection systems and liquid cooling. They also have similar suspension systems, with upside-down telescopic forks at the front and swing arms with monoshock absorbers at the rear. The chassis of both bikes is made of aluminum and has a twin-tube frame design.

In terms of braking, the BMW S 1000 R has larger double disk brakes with a diameter of 320 mm at the front, while the Yamaha MT-09 has slightly smaller double disk brakes with a diameter of 298 mm. This gives the BMW better stopping power and control.

BMW S 1000 R 2021

BMW S 1000 R 2021

Both bikes come with advanced rider assistance systems such as ABS and traction control. However, the BMW S 1000 R offers additional features like hill start assist, riding modes, cornering ABS, ride by wire, and anti-wheelie control. These features enhance the overall safety and performance of the BMW.

In terms of dimensions and weights, the BMW S 1000 R has a slightly wider front tire width of 120 mm compared to the Yamaha MT-09's 120 mm. The rear tire width of the BMW is also wider at 190 mm compared to the Yamaha's 180 mm. The wheelbase of the BMW is longer at 1450 mm compared to the Yamaha's 1430 mm. The seat height of the BMW is slightly higher at 830 mm compared to the Yamaha's 825 mm. However, the Yamaha MT-09 is lighter with a kerb weight of 189 kg compared to the BMW's 199 kg.

In terms of fuel tank capacity, the BMW S 1000 R has a larger capacity of 16.5 liters compared to the Yamaha MT-09's 14 liters. This gives the BMW a longer range and reduces the need for frequent refueling.

In terms of strengths, the BMW S 1000 R is praised for its powerful engine, good brakes, comfortable ergonomics, and high-performance optional extras. It is also considered a great all-rounder, suitable for various riding conditions.

Yamaha MT-09 2021

Yamaha MT-09 2021

On the other hand, the Yamaha MT-09 is praised for its lack of load change reactions, strong performance in the center, and a comprehensive electronics package. It also has a well-integrated seating position, successful chassis, lively handling, and provides enormous riding pleasure.

In terms of weaknesses, the BMW S 1000 R is criticized for its quickshifter, which is good but not perfect, and its slightly intrusive sound. It also has some vibrations in the handlebars.

The Yamaha MT-09 is criticized for its polarizing look, small TFT display, somewhat indirect front wheel feel, and the fact that cruise control is only available in the SP variant.

Overall, both the BMW S 1000 R and the Yamaha MT-09 are impressive naked bikes with their own strengths and weaknesses. The BMW offers more power, advanced rider assistance systems, and a larger fuel tank capacity. The Yamaha, on the other hand, offers a comprehensive electronics package, a comfortable seating position, and lively handling. Ultimately, the choice between the two models will depend on the rider's preferences and priorities.

Technical Specifications BMW S 1000 R 2021 compared to Yamaha MT-09 2021

BMW S 1000 R 2021
Yamaha MT-09 2021

Engine and Drive Train

Engine typeEngine typeIn lineEngine typeIn line
BoreBore80 mmBore78 mm
StrokeStroke49.7 mmStroke62.1 mm
Engine powerEngine power165 HPEngine power119 HP
Rpm at Max. PowerRpm at Max. Power11,000 rpmRpm at Max. Power10,000 rpm
TorqueTorque114 NmTorque93 Nm
Rpm at TorqueRpm at Torque9,250 rpmRpm at Torque7,000 rpm
Compression RatioCompression Ratio12.5 Compression Ratio11.5
Fuel systemFuel systemInjectionFuel systemInjection
StarterStarterElectricStarterElectric
Clutch TypeClutch TypeMultiplate in oil-bath, AntihoppingClutch TypeMultiplate in oil-bath
TransmissionTransmissionChainTransmissionChain
Transmission TypeTransmission TypeGearshiftTransmission TypeGearshift
Number of gearsNumber of gears6Number of gears6
CylindersCylinders4Cylinders3
StrokesStrokes4-StrokeStrokes4-Stroke
Valves per cylinderValves per cylinder4Valves per cylinder4
ValvesValvesDOHC, Drag leverValvesDOHC
CoolingCoolingliquidCoolingliquid
DisplacementDisplacement999 ccmDisplacement889 ccm

Suspension Front

Front suspensionFront suspensionUpside-Down telescopic forkFront suspensionUpside-Down telescopic fork
TravelTravel120 mmTravel130 mm

Suspension Rear

SuspensionSuspensionSwing armSuspensionSwing arm
Shock absorberShock absorberMonoshockShock absorberMonoshock
TravelTravel117 mmTravel122 mm

Chassis

FrameFrameAluminiumFrameAluminium
Frame typeFrame typeTwin TubeFrame typeTwin Tube
RakeRake66 degreeRake65 degree
TrailTrail96.3 mmTrail108 mm

Brakes Front

TypeTypeDouble diskTypeDouble disk
DiameterDiameter320 mmDiameter298 mm

Brakes Rear

TypeTypeDiscTypeDisc
DiameterDiameter220 mmDiameter245 mm

Assistance Systems

Advanced Rider Assistance SystemsAdvanced Rider Assistance SystemsABS, Hill start assist, Riding modes, Cornering ABS, Ride by Wire, Traction control, Anti-wheelieAdvanced Rider Assistance SystemsABS, Quickshifter, Traction control

Dimensions and Weights

Front tyre widthFront tyre width120 mmFront tyre width120 mm
Front tyre heightFront tyre height70 %Front tyre height70 %
Front tyre diameterFront tyre diameter17 inchFront tyre diameter17 inch
Rear tyre widthRear tyre width190 mmRear tyre width180 mm
Rear tyre heightRear tyre height55 %Rear tyre height55 %
Rear tyre diameterRear tyre diameter17 inchRear tyre diameter17 inch
LengthLength2,090 mmLength2,090 mm
WidthWidth812 mmWidth795 mm
WheelbaseWheelbase1,450 mmWheelbase1,430 mm
Seat HeightSeat Height830 mmSeat Height825 mm
Kerb Weight (with ABS)Kerb Weight (with ABS)199 kgKerb Weight (with ABS)189 kg
Fuel Tank CapacityFuel Tank Capacity16.5 lFuel Tank Capacity14 l
License compliancyLicense compliancyALicense compliancyA

Pros and Cons in comparison

Pros and Cons in comparison

BMW S 1000 R 2021

BMW S 1000 R 2021

The seating position is sporty, but by no means uncomfortable, the brakes are powerful and the engine of the S 1000 R is at its best - perhaps even a little too homogeneous. There is also nothing to complain about on the riding side. Based on the pure performance data and the installed electronic features, the BMW probably has what it takes for the fastest lap time. And that on any kind of surface, because with the semi-active suspension you can eat up kilometre after kilometre on bad roads littered with potholes. Unfortunately, this feeling of superiority never really spilled over to the driver. Probably the downside of too much balance in all areas - at least in my Italophile eyes. The BMW lacked that certain something, the charisma, which is difficult to explain but arouses genuine emotions.

powerful engine

strong brakes

comfortable ergonomics

good standard equipment

extensive range of accessories

Sluggish shift assistant

optics not 100% coherent

Yamaha MT-09 2021

Yamaha MT-09 2021

If you take a look at the key data of the MT-09, including its over-complete standard equipment, "mid-range naked bike" almost sounds a little pejorative. The Japanese engineers have made improvements exactly where they were needed. The swaying chassis is now a thing of the past and the load change reactions have also been eliminated from the revised three-cylinder engine. The additional power paired with a little more pressure in the mid-range gives a sovereign riding feeling. The MT-09 offers a lot of equipment and enormous riding pleasure at a very attractive price.

no load change reactions

plenty of pressure from the centre

over-complete electronics package

great working quickshifter

comfortably integrated seating position

successful chassis

lively handling

enormous riding pleasure

Polarising optics

small TFT display

somewhat indirect front wheel feel

cruise control only available in SP variant

Price Comparison Average Market Price BMW S 1000 R vs Yamaha MT-09

There are a few key differences between a BMW S 1000 R 2021 and a Yamaha MT-09 2021. In terms of price, the actual average price of a BMW S 1000 R 2021 is about 83% higher. Compared to Yamaha MT-09 2021 there are less BMW S 1000 R 2021 bikes available on the 1000PS.de Marketplace, specifically 15 compared to 19. It takes less time to sell a BMW S 1000 R with 67 days compared to 112 days for a Yamaha MT-09. Since model year 2014 1000PS.de editors have written 62 reviews for the BMW S 1000 R and 57 reviews for the Yamaha MT-09 since model year 2013. The first review for the BMW S 1000 R was published on 11/3/2013 and now has more than 17,300 views. This compares to more than 39,900 views for the first review on Yamaha MT-09 published on 6/10/2013.

Price BMW S 1000 R

Model year
Current average market prices

Price Yamaha MT-09

Model year
Current average market prices

Alternative Comparisons