BMW R 1200 GS 2017 vs. BMW R nineT Scrambler 2018

The BMW R 1200 GS 2017 and the BMW R nineT Scrambler 2018 are both motorcycles from BMW, but they have some key differences in their specifications and features.

In terms of engine and drive train, both motorcycles have a Boxer engine with a bore of 101 mm and a stroke of 73 mm. However, the R 1200 GS has a higher engine power of 125 HP compared to the R nineT Scrambler's 110 HP. The torque is also higher in the R 1200 GS at 125 Nm compared to the R nineT Scrambler's 116 Nm. Both motorcycles have a prop shaft transmission and 2 cylinders, but the R 1200 GS has air cooling while the R nineT Scrambler has oil-air cooling. The displacement is the same at 1170 ccm.

In terms of suspension, the R 1200 GS has a front suspension strut and a single swing arm rear suspension. On the other hand, the R nineT Scrambler has a telescopic fork front suspension and a Paralever rear suspension.

BMW R 1200 GS 2017

Both motorcycles have a steel frame, but the R 1200 GS has a twin tube load-bearing engine frame type while the R nineT Scrambler has a tubular frame type.

The braking system is the same for both motorcycles with double disk brakes at the front.

In terms of dimensions and weights, both motorcycles have the same front and rear tire width and diameter. The R 1200 GS has a slightly shorter wheelbase at 1507 mm compared to the R nineT Scrambler's 1527 mm. The seat height is also higher in the R 1200 GS at 850 mm compared to the R nineT Scrambler's 820 mm. The R 1200 GS is also heavier with a kerb weight of 238 kg compared to the R nineT Scrambler's 220 kg. The fuel tank capacity is larger in the R 1200 GS at 20 l compared to the R nineT Scrambler's 17 l.

BMW R nineT Scrambler 2018

In terms of strengths, the R 1200 GS is praised for its mature concept, strong engine, easy handling, powerful brakes, adjustable modes and traction control, extensive equipment range, and good image and value retention. On the other hand, the R nineT Scrambler is praised for its characterful Boxer engine, comfortable chassis, pleasant seating position, powerful brakes, cool looks, and lower price compared to the R nineT.

However, the R 1200 GS has some weaknesses including many features that come at an extra cost and the boxer engine being exposed in tough terrain. The R nineT Scrambler has a rather hard saddle and a spartan dashboard, lacking a rev counter and gear indicator in the base model.

Overall, the R 1200 GS and the R nineT Scrambler are both impressive motorcycles with their own unique strengths and weaknesses. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and the intended use of the motorcycle.